Attempted Murder Case Not Proven

Kinloch Lawyers Client Facing 16 Years in Prison Over Circumstantial Evidence

‍Kinloch Lawyers represented a client at the High Court in Glasgow.

Client is charged with attempted murder using a machete while wearing a mask

What is Circumstantial Evidence? 

Circumstantial evidence consists of facts or inferences that indirectly suggest a conclusion about an event, such as the guilt or innocence of an accused person. It contrasts with direct evidence, which directly proves a fact (e.g., eyewitness testimony).

Circumstantial evidence is admissible and can form the basis of a conviction if it leads to a compelling and reasonable conclusion of guilt.

In Scotland, as elsewhere, circumstantial evidence must meet the standard of beyond reasonable doubt for a conviction.

Circumstantial evidence is often pieced together into a "chain" to strengthen a case, but any "weak link" in the chain can undermine its reliability.

The Evidence in this case?

It was alleged that our client's car was at the scene of the crime and that their nickname was used during the incident, but no formal identification has been made.

Not Proven Verdict

A "not proven" verdict results in the accused being acquitted, just as with "not guilty."

The Decision of the Court

What was Agreed

In this case the jury unanimously agreed that there was insufficient evidence to convict our client.

Kinloch Lawyers Client Delighted  

The client was extremely grateful to our Mr Jenkins and to the team at David Kinloch and Co for all their hard work. The client was delighted that the matter was now at an end and that he was acquitted of the charge.